Historic mill wheel at Colpoy’s Bay

Colpoy’s Bay · Places & people

Story 15 / 17

Edgehill Cemetery

The location of the local cemetery in Colpoy's Bay is perhaps one of the most picturesque imaginable. Perched on the brink of a steep ridge at the north end of the village, Edgehill Cemetery offers an unrivaled view of Colpoy's Bay and the village that bears its name. (See, for instance, Figure 8C on the "Albemarle Street" page of this website.)

The first recorded burial at the cemetery, dated 1872, was the infant daughter of George and Hannah Bull and granddaughter of William Bull, the first settler in the area surrounding Colpoy's Bay village. (William settled on a large cliffside farm lot south of county road 9 at the top of Spragge's Hill in 1857 shortly before the arrival of John Wood. However, Mr. Bull's property was part of Amabel township, outside of Albemarle township and Colpoy's Bay village.) Figure 14A shows an early view of a sparsely-used Edgehill Cemetery. Unfortunately, I know neither the date nor the identities of the people shown in this image.

From the collection

Figure 14A
Figure 14A — Date unknown
Figure 14A: An early view of Edgehill Cemetery in Colpoy's Bay. (Date and persons unknown.)

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

In its early years, the cemetery suffered from insufficient maintenance (like many early cemeteries around the country) as families failed to keep up their plots. The township began keeping someone on the payroll to tend to the grounds (including my great-great-grandfather Henry Kalbfleisch who performed these duties from 1899 until 1927). However, more significant action had to be taken around the 1940s as early gravestones (which had been placed on top of the graves rather than beside them) began to tilt or collapse. A cemetery board was established, whose first project was to level the cemetery grounds and reposition tombstones on cement foundations at the head of each gravesite. The current gates at the entrance to the cemetery were erected in 1945, and include prominent names of board members.

Originally, the cemetery grounds took the shape of a "T". The stem of the "T" was an entrance off of Albemarle St. (Bruce County road 9). This was flanked on each side by private lots. Behind these lots was the burial area, forming the top of the "T". Figure 14B shows the entrance to the cemetery in the late 1940s. On the left is a house built in the early 1890s for John Fraser (blacksmith). Henry Kalbfleisch, my great-great-grandfather, purchased this house in 1897 and lived there for over twenty years. Around 1905, after his marriage, his son Edwin (my great-grandfather) purchased the house. Henry continued living there after the sale. Edwin later bought the Kalbfleisch House along the shore in 1920 (see the "Kalbfleisch House" page of this website). This house was torn down around 1950 to expand Edgehill Cemetery (although the actual footprint of the house still remains unoccupied by graves today). The house built to the south of the cemetery entrance (not visible in Figure 14B) was also built in the 1890s for James McDonagh (who built a new home one lot to the south in 1897). For some years, this house served as the church parsonage, but has long since returned to private hands.

From the collection

Figure 14B
Figure 14B — Late 1940s
Figure 14B: The entrance to Edgehill Cemetery before expansion. (Late 1940s.)

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

Most of the founders of Colpoy's Bay village lie buried in Edgehill Cemetery. Notable families such as Wood, Whicher, Kalbfleisch, Carver, Cunningham, Parke, and several others remain etched in stone in the oldest part of the cemetery. Along with them stand other key names from the area outside Colpoy's Bay village such as Alexander McNeill (Bruce County MP from 1882 to 1908 and owner of the Corran estate), and Dr. Hiram Wigle (one of Wiarton's early doctors; opened a long-running pharmacy in 1890).

After so many decades of serene peace, December 28, 2008 saw this oldest section of Edgehill Cemetery disturbed by a strange coincidence of weather-related issues. A sudden thaw, along with rain the day before, somehow caused a significant section of the cemetery's south side to erode and collapse down the hillside. Figure 14C shows three views of the devastated area.

From the collection

Figure 14C
Figure 14C — December 29, 2008 · first view
Figure 14C — December 29, 2008 · second view
Figure 14C — December 29, 2008 · third view
Figure 14C: Damage to Edgehill Cemetery (Dec. 29, 2008).

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

In the months that followed, the Town of South Bruce Peninsula worked to notify affected families (family members were located for about 90% of the affected graves). Archaeologists were also hired to meticulously sift through the soil to collect any human remains. Meanwhile, the affected gravestones were carefully placed out of harm's way, temporarily at the northeast corner of the cemetery. Once the archaeological work was complete, the gravestones and remains were re-interred in the northern section of the cemetery. In October of 2010, a large stone monument was erected at the southern end of the cemetery, near the site of the collapse.

Figure 14D shows the memorial, along with a close-up of the listing of graves that were affected by the landslide.

From the collection

Figure 14D
Figure 14D — January 1, 2011 · memorial
Figure 14D — January 1, 2011 · close-up
Figure 14D: Memorial to those gravesites affected by the 28 December 2008 landslide. (Jan. 1, 2011).

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

Follow your curiosity

Explore by Topic

Two places. A shared history.

Continue exploring

Around the collection

Resources & connections