Historic entrance gates to Wiarton

Wiarton · Places & people

Story 17 / 23

Wiarton’s Hospital

Click here to visit the official website of the Wiarton hospital
(now part of the Brightshores Health System)

In the early days, medical services in Wiarton, like those in most small Canadian communities, consisted of a small number of independent doctors, and later, private hospitals or nursing homes. About 1920, Charles and Caroline Gilbert opened a private nursing home in their home at 704 Gould Street. Caroline slowly began scaling back the nursing home during the 1930s as her age advanced. It closed fully by the early 1940s. (Keith Gilbert, grandson of Charles and Caroline Gilbert and former editor of the Wiarton Echo, provided a personal article he's written on the Gilbert nursing home.) In September 1929 Mrs. Garney Porter opened a private hospital at the south edge of town (10179 Highway 6 today). A nursery was added to the rear in January 1938 and Porter's Private Hospital continued in operation until closing its doors in June 1943. Mrs. William Root ran a private hospital at 379 Frank Street from 1931 until Miss SM Scales took over in 1937. It appears to have closed a couple of years later as Spears' Nursing Home (377 Frank St.) opened next door to the former Root private hospital in July 1939 and ran until at least 1948. Finally, Lisk's Nursing Home at the south end of town (approximately 296 Berford St.) operated at least throughout the early to mid-1940s. Figure W17A shows the buildings used for each of these businesses.

Recollections of the Gilbert Nursing Home/HospitalWritten and provided to me by Keith Gilbert (Oct. 2024)

According to the Standard College Dictionary a hospital is a building or institution "that provides medical, surgical, or psychiatric treatment and nursing care for the ill or injured temporarily lodged there.” Under that definition, it could be concluded that the first hospital in Wiarton was located at the home of Charles and Caroline Gilbert, 704 Gould Street, still standing today… unless there were others that were not recorded.

While lacking the medical machinery that was later installed in the Porter Hospital, the Gilbert Hospital still managed to fill an immediate need in the community for over 20 years.

Caroline Gilbert was known throughout the Peninsula as a healer of sorts. Her knowledge of herbs, medicines, midwifery, nursing and charms aimed at awakening self healing, brought many people to the Gilbert farm located just north of the village of Colpoy's Bay. Sometimes farmers also called on “Grandma Gilbert” when an animal was sick.

Influenced by a series of events that had a staggering impact on the Peninsula and the world in general, Caroline, Charles and youngest child Bud moved to Wiarton around 1919 with a desire to start a health care home there.

The Great War (World War One) ended November 11th, 1918, with a tragic loss of life. The Peninsula didn't go untouched with many young men paying the ultimate sacrifice.

Around the same time, something a lot more deadly than the war was killing people far more indiscriminately. A flu-like virus called the Spanish Influenza was sweeping the world, often carried by the soldiers returning to their own countries and homes. It has been estimated that the war caused the deaths of 20 million people in four and a half years. In the same period at its epidemic rate, influenza would have killed 108 million making it five times more deadly than the war. It lasted 1918 to 1920. In January, February and March of 1919, it was estimated that some 6 million persons had perished from influenza and pneumonia.

The Peninsula didn't escape the disease known as the “Black Death.” When two young brothers from Lion's Head suffering with the flu were brought to Wiarton for medical attention, there was no home to house them. They were put up in the Pacific Hotel where they died shortly after. This drove home the obvious desperate need for health care facilities so by 1920, the Gilbert Hospital was busy treating and caring for patients with Caroline and area doctors often going for days without rest tending to men, women and children sick and dying.

Bud, 87 at the time of this interview in 1992, and his wife Ann recalled a number of unpleasant incidents that happened at the hospital. One man had a leg that was badly infected and plans were made to cut it off. "I didn't want to hang around and listen.” He remembered sneaking out a bedroom window to get away. He said he was around 14 at the time.

They both remembered a burn victim brought into the hospital. "I'm not sure what happened to him but he was in terrible shape. Grandma (Caroline) had a knife and was smearing some sort of salve over him. I don't recall all the details," said Ann who worked at the hospital just prior to her marriage to Bud in mid-1937.

"I also saw my first Black Mariah here. I can remember it quite well." She described it as a horse-drawn bob-sled used to transport the deceased in winter.

Ann explained that as patients came in they were treated and released as quickly as possible and that many babies were delivered there. Caroline was also “fetched” to deliver a baby or provide temporary care to a sick or injured person in their own home.

While no records were kept, Bud recalled various medical Doctors who performed operations there; Drs. Charlie and Hiram Wigle, Dr. Hay, Dr. Emerson Scott, Dr. Fischer and Dr. Hartry.

They also remembered two nurses who worked there, May McVannel and Jean Currie, but said that Grandma did most of the nursing over the years.

Not in the best health and getting on in age, “Grandma started slowly closing down the hospital in the 1930s, still supplying poultices and salves and sometimes boarding an older patient,” said Ann.

Even when Grandma Gilbert was in her 90s, people would still drop in for some of her famous “black salve” and she was available to remove warts from people using some mystical process that involved the new moon. Caroline died in 1959.

Bud died in 1995 and Ann died in 2001. Shortly after, the former hospital was sold, but is still standing today.

Gilbert Nursing Home and Caroline Gilbert

Gilbert Nursing Home and Caroline Gilbert — c. 1920

Gilbert Nursing Home (c. 1920).

Gilbert Nursing Home and Caroline Gilbert — 1999

Former Gilbert Nursing Home (1999).

Gilbert Nursing Home and Caroline Gilbert — c. 1940 · Caroline Gilbert

Caroline Gilbert (c. 1940).

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

First: Gilbert Nursing Home (c. 1920); Second: Former Gilbert Nursing Home (1999); Third: Caroline Gilbert (c. 1940).

From the collection

Figure W17A
Figure W17A — 2024 · Gilbert
Figure W17A — 2010 · Porter
Figure W17A — 2009 · Root & Spears
Figure W17A — 2010 · Lisk
Figure W17A: Former locations of Wiarton's private hospitals and nursing homes. (First: Gilbert's Nursing Home - 2024; Second: Porter's Private Hospital - 2010; Third (l-r): Root's Private Hospital and Spears' Nursing Home (2009); Fourth: Lisk's Nursing Home (2010)).

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

By the mid-1930s, however, some had begun noting the benefits of attracting a Red Cross hospital to town. In February of 1937, a representative of the Canadian Red Cross Society visited Wiarton to present a case for establishing a 15-bed hospital in town. The cost of setting up the hospital in a new building was estimated to be between $25 000 and $40 000 at the time. The Red Cross would have full control of the hospital, and would cover any annual operating deficits.

However, plans for a new hospital in Wiarton were put on hold with the outbreak of the Second World War in 1939. As the war stretched on, the need for a local hospital once again became a top priority in 1944, in part because the closure of Porter's Private Hospital the previous year left the town with no registered hospitals, only nursing homes. In June of 1944, an agreement was reached in principle between the town, the Women's Institute, the Rotary Club, the Board of Trade and the Red Cross to erect a hospital in Wiarton named "The Bruce Peninsula Memorial Hospital" in memory of the area's fallen soldiers, although the site had not yet been chosen. Figure W17B shows an artist's drawing of the proposed hospital (with accompanying description) published in October 1944.

From the collection

Figure W17B
Figure W17B — c. October 26, 1944
Figure W17B: Artist's drawing of the proposed hospital in Wiarton (c. Oct. 26, 1944).

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

In the end, the Red Cross agreed to pay one-third of the $200 000 cost (about $2.8 million in today's money) with another third covered by the provincial government and the remainder paid for by the federal government and local donations. Figure W17C shows a donation form printed in the local newspaper November 7th, 1944.

From the collection

Figure W17C
Figure W17C — November 7, 1944
Figure W17C: Donation form for the proposed Bruce Peninsula Memorial Hospital (November 7, 1944).

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

Located on land donated by the Greenlees family (to the southwest of where the Hill Chair factory once stood), construction began on the ten-room Red Cross Outpost Hospital in 1947 with the cornerstone laid October 5, 1949. The new building was designed in a distinctive symmetric Georgian style of architecture, featuring a central section with a stone facade, ground-floor shuttered windows and second-storey dormer windows. This central section was flanked on each side by a stone chimney and a proportionate diagonally-oriented wing. I have always found the architecture of the Wiarton hospital a welcome departure from the plain box-like structures that have sprung up around Ontario since the beginning of the 1960s. Interestingly, two other hospitals were built to the same design, in Nipigon and Burk's Falls.

After just over two years of operating the hospital, the Red Cross sold it to the Town of Wiarton at the beginning of 1952, at which time it was renamed the Bruce Peninsula and District Hospital. In 1968, the building received a 23-bed addition to the rear of the building and significant improvements throughout. The following year, the basement was also renovated to hold dental and medical offices. Figure W17D shows the hospital as it stood in the early 1960s.

From the collection

Figure W17D
Figure W17D — c. 1960
Figure W17D: Bruce Peninsula and District Memorial Hospital (about 1960).

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

After 45 years of service, the decision was made to replace Wiarton's hospital with a completely new structure. The original hospital served out its last days as its larger replacement took form just behind it to the east. In 1994, the original Red Cross hospital was torn down and the new hospital opened its doors...a vast improvement in size and facilities. In 1998, Wiarton joined five other hospitals in Grey Bruce Health Services, which was renamed Brightshores Health System in 2023.

As you can see in Figure W17E, the present hospital features a more modern style of architecture, while still retaining key references to its predecessor (notably the stone facade and the large second-storey triangular windows that echo the dormer windows of the original building).

From the collection

Figure W17E
Figure W17E — 2003
Figure W17E — 2023
Figure W17E: The current Wiarton Hospital (2003, 2023)

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

Although Wiarton's original hospital is now a thing of the past, the last of the three hospitals designed to the same specifications remains in Burk's Falls. Figure W17F shows how little the exterior of the Burk's Falls hospital changed in over the half-century between 1957 and 2006. Indeed, the second view from 2006 gives one a sense of looking at the ghost of Wiarton's original Red Cross hospital.

From the collection

Figure W17F
Figure W17F — c. 1957
Figure W17F — 2006
Figure W17F: The hospital in Burk's Falls, Ontario. The last of three hospitals designed to the same specifications as Wiarton's original Red Cross Hospital. (c. 1957, 2006)

Select a photograph to enlarge it in the image viewer.

Today, Wiarton's hospital continues to stand as a reminder of the fallen war heroes in whose name it was originally erected.

Follow your curiosity

Explore by Topic

Two places. A shared history.

Continue exploring

Around the collection

Resources & connections